So Italian

Nestled in the heart of Brownsburg, Indiana, So Italian is a vibrant Italian restaurant that brings authentic flavors straight from Italy to your plate. Located at 515 E Main St, this charming spot is a must-visit for anyone craving classic Italian comfort food served with a fresh, modern twist. From the moment you enter, the inviting aroma of herbs, garlic, and simmering sauces sets the scene for a truly satisfying dining experience.

The menu at So Italian is a treasure trove of Italian favorites, thoughtfully crafted to satisfy every palate. Popular highlights include Ryan’s Bread Sticks—warm, fluffy, and perfectly seasoned to pair with any meal—and the ever-popular Pepperoni Pizza Slice loaded with savory, melted cheese and pepperoni that crisps at the edges. For those seeking a hearty dish, their Meat Lasagna is a rich, layered masterpiece dripping with robust marinara and creamy ricotta that melts in your mouth.

So Italian also shines with inventive gluten-free pizzas, a thoughtful offering that doesn’t compromise on flavor. The GF Chicken Ranchero, featuring ranch sauce, grilled chicken, and a mix of cheddar and mozzarella cheese, delivers a tantalizing blend of creamy, smoky, and fresh notes. Equally delightful is the GF Feta Florentine, brimming with spinach, roasted red peppers, and tangy feta cheese, crafting a well-balanced, vibrant flavor profile.

Diners rave about the Fettuccine Alfredo’s luscious, velvety sauce that clings perfectly to every strand of pasta, making it an indulgent treat that feels like a warm hug. And if you’re after a satisfying sandwich, the Chicken Parmesan Sub stacks crispy, breaded chicken smothered with marinara and mozzarella, all nestled in a soft, fresh roll.

No Italian meal is complete without a sweet finale, and So Italian delivers with traditional Cannoli filled with imported ricotta and mascarpone—a crisp pastry shell encasing a creamy, lightly sweet filling that offers the perfect balance of textures. For a fun twist, the Nutella Pizza is an irresistible 12-inch dessert pizza that combines the silky richness of Nutella with a soft, warm crust. Or you can indulge in the Tiramisu, a lovingly prepared classic layered cake that’s both elegant and comforting.

Beyond the food, So Italian prides itself on a casual, family-friendly atmosphere that feels welcoming and relaxed. Customers appreciate the efficient service, where you order at the counter and your food arrives swiftly, fresh and piping hot. Whether you're stopping by for an early dinner or grabbing a hearty takeout, patrons consistently remark on the friendly staff who add a personal touch to the experience.

Reviewers consistently highlight the combination of quality and value. Bob Andersen loved the rich, creamy sauce on his Chicken Alfredo and the crispy, perfectly chewy calzone crust, while Nathaniel Wilcox praised the speedy service and delicious spaghetti. Amber Franks emphasized the generous portions perfect for leftovers, and Ron Vernick noted the restaurant’s accommodating gluten-free options as a big plus for his repeated visits.

While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, as with any authentic spot, tastes vary—some have found certain dishes less to their liking, which speaks to the honest, diverse experiences one can expect at an independent local eatery. This transparency and the overall dedication to delivering genuine Italian fare keep So Italian a beloved doorway to Italy in Brownsburg.

Whether you’re a devoted Italian food lover or looking to explore classic flavors with a welcoming neighborhood vibe, So Italian offers a compelling menu with satisfying dishes that feel homemade and heartfelt. For a taste of Italy right in Indiana, it’s a destination that warmly invites you back time and time again.